Buying a trained protection dog is one of the few purchases where you can’t easily check what you’re getting. You buy the dog trained because you don’t have the skills to train it yourself. That same gap makes it hard to tell whether the dog actually knows what you’ve been promised.
And this isn’t a short-term buy. A dog is a 12 to 14 year commitment, closer to a marriage than a shopping trip. Get it wrong and you lose a lot of money and live with the result for years.
Like any industry, ours has people working hard to do it right and people working hard to get money out of your pocket. Here’s how we’d go about buying a protection dog if we were in your shoes.
1. Know what you actually want
Before you contact anyone, get clear on what you need. A lot of buyers who feel scammed simply had a picture in their head that no dog was ever going to match.
We’ve had some truly out-there requests over the years. Maybe someone somewhere can train those things into a dog, but we haven’t met them. If your expectations are unrealistic, do more homework before you buy.
Ask yourself honestly which of these you’re after:
- A security dog that works a job.
- A companion that lives with you and can protect you if it has to.
- A security company that looks after you and your home.
If you expect your dog to search the house and sweep the property every time you get home, you’re hoping for too much. That’s a job for a security company.
Then look at your day-to-day life. How does a dog fit into it? What kind of dog suits the way you actually live? Once you can answer that, you’re ready to start talking to sellers.
2. Talk about price first, and ask where the savings come from
Price is the elephant in the room, so deal with it first. It tells you quickly whether a seller is right for you and whether you can afford the dog.
These dogs are expensive for a simple reason: they take one to two years to train. Think about anything in your own business that takes two years to produce, and what that costs.
People regularly ask us to sell a dog for less than it costs us to raise it for a year. When another company does sell below cost, our first question is: where are they cutting?
- Are they cutting on food?
- Are they sacrificing the dog’s health?
- Are they saving on time, with the dog sitting in a kennel and coming out once a week?
Circus tricks versus a dog you can live with
The cheapest way to “train” a dog looks like this. The trainer takes it out in the morning for 10 to 15 minutes of sits, downs and stays, then puts it back in the kennel. A good trainer might do a second session in the afternoon. That’s half an hour a day.
We call those sits and downs circus tricks. They look good, but they don’t tell you how the dog behaves in your life:
- Does it barge through doors?
- Does it jump up on you or your guests?
- Does it stand still while you put its gear on?
- Does it get into and out of the car on command? Has it ever been in a car?
- Has it met other people on walks? Does it pull on the lead?
- Does it come back when you call it?
Everyone loves a lightning-fast sit. But unless you compete in IGP or PSA, how pretty the sit looks doesn’t matter. We’d rather the dog came back when called.
A well-mannered dog takes three to four hours a day, not half an hour. It means living with the dog in the house, in the car, taking it to restaurants, and getting it used to people, cats and even parrots. That’s where the cost goes, and that’s what you’re really paying for. Spend more and get a better dog, rather than grabbing whatever is on special.
3. Ask for raw footage, not music videos
Once price is settled, ask for videos and photos. But not just any videos.
You’ll almost always be sent bite work first. Heavy metal blaring, a dog hitting a decoy and taking him to the ground. It’s impressive, and you’ll want to show your friends. It’s also the edited, staged version, and it tells you very little.
Ask for unedited footage of the dog out of its comfort zone, away from the place it grew up and its kennel:
- A walk in a park, on lead, with kids kicking a ball around. Keep it on lead, since you don’t yet know how it’s trained. You’ll see its real obedience and how it listens.
- Getting into and out of a car.
- A recall while the dog is distracted, playing or sniffing around. It doesn’t have to sit in front of the handler like a little soldier. It just needs to come back and say “here I am.” That shows the dog has been socialised and properly worked.
- Letting go of a toy. The dog should release it happily and not snap at it again. If the trainer has to wrestle the toy away, that’s usually the bit cut from the music video.
If you know someone with dog experience, show them the footage and ask what they think.
Don’t rely on the trainer telling you what a fantastic dog it is. It’s the second-hand car salesman’s line: the old lady only drove it to church. Let the raw footage speak instead.
4. Ask about the dog’s weaknesses
Every dog has weaknesses, just as every person does. There’s no perfect dog, in the same way there’s no perfect car or machine. That’s why there’s a spare parts industry.
Ask the seller for the dog’s strengths and its weaknesses. A good protection dog company knows its dogs well enough to answer straight away. If they can’t name a single weakness, be wary.
Then ask yourself the harder question: how will I manage those weaknesses? Do I have the knowledge to work with a dog like this? Being honest here saves a lot of frustration later.
5. Find out what support you get after handover
You’ve got the dog home. Now what?
Many of our clients have owned pets before, and some have trained a dog of their own. But going from a pet to your first working dog isn’t a step up. It’s a leap. There are things you’ll need to focus on that you never had to think about before.
The first six months are an interesting time. You’ll learn a lot about the dog and about yourself. During that time you need someone to hold your hand, ideally the people who raised and trained that dog, because they know it best. You might see it doing something with its teeth and think it’s about to eat you, when it’s really just that grin it does.
Then one day something clicks. It’s a bit like a dragon rider bonding with his dragon. You start a command and the dog finishes it before you do. You stand up to go to the car and the dog already knows. That’s when you can let go of the hand.
You should still be able to pick up the phone if something comes up or you want to teach the dog something new. So before you buy, ask exactly what handover and ongoing support looks like.
6. Make sure you click with the people you buy from
Not every personality gets along, and that’s fine. But you’ll be walking a long road with this seller, so choose people you’re comfortable picking up the phone to. If you dread contacting them, you won’t ask for help when you need it.
Even between the two of us, some clients prefer talking to Marilé and others prefer Charles. Charles is the loud one; Marilé is quieter and more technical. Nothing personal, just different personalities.
You’re spending a lot of money, and this is an emotional decision as much as a practical one. You’re buying a personality. Make sure you like the people behind it too.
7. Meet the dog away from home, if you can
Ideally, go and meet the dog yourself, and meet it outside its usual surroundings. A park or a dog-friendly restaurant shows you who the dog really is.
We know that isn’t always possible. Flying 21 hours to meet a dog, or taking time off work, isn’t realistic for everyone. So treat it as preferable, not essential, and lean harder on the raw footage when you can’t be there.
Your checklist before you buy
- Decide what you really need: a companion that can protect, a security dog, or a security company.
- Get the price on the table, and ask any cheap seller where they cut costs.
- Ask for raw, unedited footage: on-lead walks in public, car loading, a distracted recall, and a happy toy release.
- Ask for the dog’s weaknesses as well as its strengths, and decide whether you can manage them.
- Find out what handover and ongoing support you’ll get, especially in the first six months.
- Make sure you get on with the people selling the dog.
- Meet the dog away from home if you can.
Have you bought a protection dog before? If something happened to you that we haven’t covered, share it in the comments. Your experience could save the next buyer a lot of money and heartache.